Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies: 1 Great Recipe

Oh, the holidays! Everyone always rushes around trying to make complicated, fussy treats, and honestly, my kitchen used to look like a blizzard hit it every December trying to keep up. But you know what? I cracked the code for you this year. Forget the stress! These are, hands down, the Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays you will ever need in your life. Peppermint makes everything feel instantly festive, right? That cool, bright flavor cuts through all the heavy chocolate and sugar, and it’s just non-negotiable for me.

After years of tweaking recipes that promised miracles but delivered messes, I focused on making this one absolutely foolproof. We’re talking simple measuring, minimal chilling, and maximum payoff. Trust me, this recipe for Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays is going to be your new holiday staple because it’s so incredibly easy to manage, even when you’re juggling wrapping paper and family gatherings.

Why You Will Bake These Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

I know you’re probably drowning in holiday baking lists right now, but I promise you need to stop everything and try these. They are just the best combination of quick, pretty, and unbelievably tasty. Seriously, why bother with anything complicated?

• These cookies are done, start to finish, before you finish your first cup of eggnog—that’s efficiency!
• They have that perfect little snap when you bite into the peppermint topping, which is pure holiday joy.
• These are the only Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays you’ll ever need because they stay soft and yummy all week long (if they last that long, which they won’t!).
• It’s one of those recipes where the result looks way more impressive than the effort you put in. Perfect for looking like a baking rockstar!

Quick Prep Time for Your Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

When I say quick, I mean it. We are looking at only about 20 minutes of actual work before these babies hit the oven. That’s huge when you have a million other things to organize for Christmas or New Year’s. You don’t need to chill this dough for hours, either, which saves so much time compared to traditional cutout cookies. You can mix these up right after dinner and still have time to watch a holiday movie!

Simple Ingredients for Easy Peppermint Cookies

You won’t need to make a special trip to three different boutique stores for this recipe. Everything here is standard pantry stuff—flour, sugar, butter, egg. The real magic, obviously, is the peppermint extract and the crushed candies on top. If you have a big jar of those classic red-and-white striped mints, you’re halfway there! For more advanced tips on getting your base baking ingredients just right, check out my general guide on baking tips to make you a better baker, but honestly, for this one, the technique is already built-in to be simple!

Gathering Ingredients for Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

Okay, gathering our supplies! Since this recipe is so super quick, you don’t want to realize halfway through mixing that you’re out of something crucial. Clarity here is how we guarantee success. I’ve listed everything out, just like on my own shopping list, so you can see exactly what needs to be ready to go when you start mixing. We’ve got our base dry components, our fats and sugars, and then the stars of the show: the extracts and the mint!

You’ll need one cup of unsalted butter that’s properly softened—not melted, just soft enough to give when you press it gently. Make sure you have a large egg ready, a teaspoon of vanilla extract, and almost three cups of flour, plus baking soda and salt for structure. The flavor punch comes from half a teaspoon of peppermint extract. Don’t skimp on the peppermint; it’s what makes these cookies scream “holiday!”

Don’t forget the topping! The recipe calls for a quarter cup of crushed peppermint candies, which is usually what you get when you smash up some good old-fashioned candy canes in a Ziploc bag. This is the fun part, but be thorough!

Ingredient Notes and Substitutions for Peppermint Cookies

About those crushed peppermint candies on top—if you’re using actual candy canes, you have to be careful. If you blitz them too fine in a food processor, they can almost dissolve into a weird syrup when they hit the hot cookie. I usually prefer putting them inside a heavy-duty bag and just pounding them lightly with the bottom of a skillet or a rolling pin. You want nice little chunks, not dust.

If you happen to be out of pure peppermint extract, you *could* try a drop of spearmint, but honestly, it just won’t taste like Christmas. Peppermint is key here. Also, resist the urge to swap out the butter for anything else. Fats matter so much in cookies like this—if you need alternatives for dietary reasons, I have some general notes on that here, but for the best result in these specific cookies? Stick to the butter.

One last thing: if you’re worried about your butter temperature, softening it correctly is vital for the creaming step to work its magic and trap all that airy goodness inside our final cookie!

Step-by-Step Instructions for Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

Alright, time to get baking! Since we want these to be the most Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays ever, speed and timing are our friends here. We’re not messing around with complicated steps. First things first: preheat that oven to 350 degrees F and line those baking sheets—don’t skip the parchment paper; I’ve ruined too many beautiful cookies by sticking them!

We’re just following the recipe card exactly, and it is streamlined for maximum home-baking joy. It’s a straightforward dump-and-mix situation, which is why I love spreading the word about how easy these are!

Mixing the Dough for Your Easy Peppermint Cookies

Grab your big bowl and cream that softened butter and the cup of sugar together first. You want it light and fluffy—I mean, really creamed well! That’s where you beat in your egg and vanilla until everything looks happy and combined. Now, in a separate, smaller bowl, whisk your flour, baking soda, and salt. I always whisk the dry stuff first so the leavening agents are perfectly distributed. Then, you gradually add those dry bits into your wet mixture. Mix slowly until you just see everything disappear. Stop mixing! Seriously, stop before you think you should. Overmixing here is the #1 way to make your easy cookies tough instead of tender. Finally, stir in that essential peppermint extract.

Baking and Finishing Your Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

Roll the dough into little balls—I aim for about 2 inches apart so they have room to spread nicely on the sheet. Here’s the fun trick: take the bottom of a drinking glass that you’ve dipped in plain sugar and lightly press down on each ball. This creates that perfect looking surface for toppings! Bake them for 8 to 10 minutes. Watch them closely; you only want light gold edges.

The crucial next move happens immediately: pull them out and *immediately* shower them with those crushed peppermint candies. They need the residual heat to stick properly. Don’t touch them yet! Let them sit right on that hot baking sheet for about 5 minutes to firm up—this two-stage cooling process prevents them from immediately breaking when you try to move them. Then, transfer them gently to a wire rack to cool totally. This little recipe is such a win; you can read more about mixing techniques in my guide on chocolate shortbread recipes, but these peppermint cookies are shockingly simple!

Tips for Perfect Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

Even though these are touted as the easiest cookies ever—and they truly are!—sometimes the dough just has a mind of its own, especially when the kitchen is warm from all that holiday oven use. I want you to have spectacular success, so here are a few little things I’ve learned over the years that guarantee these Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays come out exactly right.

Remember, baking is chemistry, but it’s also feeling. Trust your instincts, but these tips will keep you on the right track!

Troubleshooting Sticky Dough When Making Peppermint Cookies

If you followed the recipe exactly but find your dough is just too sticky to roll into neat little balls—maybe your butter was a touch too soft or your humidity is sky-high today—don’t panic! Your first instinct might be to dump in more flour, but please don’t! That’s going to make the cookies hard. Instead, wrap that sticky dough up tight and just stick it in the fridge for about 15 minutes.

Why bother chilling? Because cold is your friend when dealing with sticky cookie dough. When the butter starts to firm up again in the cold, the dough becomes manageable, easier to handle, and when you bake it, the cold fat ensures a better texture in the oven. It’s a quick fix that keeps these easy peppermint cookies perfect!

Achieving the Best Texture in Your Easy Peppermint Cookies

I mentioned this during the mixing steps, but it bears repeating because it’s the secret to keeping them feeling light and tender, not dense and chewy. Once you add the flour mixture to your butter/sugar/egg base, you must stop mixing the second you stop seeing flour streaks. I mean it! Stop the mixer, take the bowl out, and finish the tiny bit that’s left with a spatula by hand.

This prevents overdeveloping the gluten in the flour. Overmixed flour turns into a tough cookie, and we are aiming for “delightful” and “easy,” not “brick-like.” Keep that mixing quick once the flour goes in, and you’ll get that beautiful, tender crumb every time. If you want to dive deeper into flour science, I cover some basics in my guide on baking tips to make you a better baker, but for these cookies, just remember: flour in, mix minimally, done!

Serving Suggestions for Your Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

So, you’ve got two dozen (or maybe three dozen, if you’re like me and doubled this recipe already) of the most Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays cooling on the rack. Now, what are we going to eat them with? These cookies are so bright and minty, they need the perfect partner to shine, especially during those chilly evenings when you’re relaxing after fighting holiday traffic.

My absolute favorite way to enjoy these is with a big, steaming mug of something warm. That cool peppermint is gorgeous when contrasted with something rich and cozy. If you want the ultimate holiday pairing, you *have* to try making a batch of my irresistible peppermint hot chocolate recipe. Imagine dipping one of these simple cookies right into that creamy chocolate—it’s pure magic, and the double peppermint is never too much during December!

If you’re setting up a cookie plate for guests, keep it simple but elegant. These peppermint cookies look fantastic next to a plain, buttery shortbread or maybe even a dark chocolate truffle. The red and white topping just pops against darker colors. They aren’t overly sweet on their own, which means they pair really well with coffee too! I often have one mid-morning with a strong black cup—it wakes up my taste buds.

Think about presentation! If you have small glass jars or tins, these pack beautifully. Layer them with a tiny square of parchment paper between the layers so the crushed candy doesn’t stick to the cookie above it. They make fantastic little neighbor gifts because they’re so easy to transport and everyone loves a peppermint kiss during the holidays!

Storage and Make-Ahead Tips for Holiday Peppermint Cookies

One of the best things about these Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays is that they are built to last! When you’re baking around the holidays, you really need make-ahead options, and these cookies deliver. You don’t want to be washing dishes on Christmas Eve, trust me!

Since this is a butter-based, slightly crisp cookie, storage is pretty simple, but you have to be careful with the peppermint topping. We want them to stay flavorful and not get weirdly soft.

Keeping Freshness Locked In

Once the cookies are completely cool—and I mean totally, stone-cold, not even warm to the touch—you can store them in an airtight container at room temperature. I prefer using cookie tins with tight lids because they offer better protection than plastic containers sometimes. You can typically keep them fresh like this for a good week, maybe even ten days, as long as your kitchen isn’t super humid!

Make sure you don’t stack them more than two or three deep, or you risk smushing that beautiful pressed top. If you absolutely must stack higher, put a small square of parchment paper between each layer. This keeps the crushed candy pieces from falling off or getting gooey against the cookie next to it.

Freezing Your Easy Peppermint Cookies Like a Pro

This recipe freezes like a dream, which is fantastic for getting ahead of the holiday rush! You have two options here: you can freeze the baked cookies or freeze the dough balls, and both work great.

If you freeze the finished cookies: let them cool completely, then arrange them in a single layer on a baking sheet and freeze them for about an hour until they are hard little pebbles. Then, transfer those frozen cookies into a freezer-safe, heavy-duty bag or container. They keep beautifully for up to three months this way!

If you freeze the dough balls *before* adding the topping: Roll them up just like the instructions say, place them on a lined sheet, and freeze until solid. Then transfer them to a bag. When you need them, just pull out how many you want and pop them directly onto your baking sheet. Keep the baking time the same—or maybe add just a minute or two, but usually, they bake straight from frozen just fine. That way, you always have fresh easy peppermint cookies ready to go!

Frequently Asked Questions About Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays

I’ve answered just about every question under the sun regarding these cookies over the years, especially during the busy holiday season! People always want to know how to customize them or if they can skip a step. I’ve gathered the most common ones here so you can get straight to baking your batch of Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays.

Can I make these Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays without peppermint extract?

Honestly? You’re making a peppermint cookie, so it really won’t be the same without it! The peppermint extract is the whole showstopper here. If you absolutely cannot find it, you could substitute it with an equal amount of vanilla extract, but you’ll just end up with a very nice, very plain sugar cookie that needs a different topping. Or, you could try almond extract, which gives a lovely fragrant flavor that pairs decently well with butter cookies.

However, to keep the true holiday spirit, I really suggest finding the peppermint! If you want to branch out later, I have a fantastic recipe for a chocolate peppermint cheesecake that really lets that flavor shine in a different way. But for these easy peppermint cookies? Stick to the mint flavor!

How do I get the best color on my easy peppermint cookies?

This is where we lean into the fun, bright visuals of the season! The cookie dough itself is a pale gold, which is lovely, but it’s the topping that brings the festive cheer. The best color comes from being intentional with your crushed candies, just like I mentioned earlier.

You want to use the classic red and white striped peppermint candies. When you crush them, make sure you have a mix of colors and sizes—some fine dust and some chunkier pieces. When you immediately sprinkle these on the hot cookies right out of the oven, the red colors really stand out against the pale cookie base. It makes them look like little jewels on top, which is way more fun than just plain white sugar. It really elevates the look of these Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays even though the process is so simple!

Estimated Nutritional Snapshot for These Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies

I know, I know, when we’re talking about Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays, we are definitely not reaching for a nutrition label first! But I always feel better having this information handy, especially when those little snowmen and Christmas sweater-wearing neighbors pop by wanting one (or three!).

This is just a quick look at what’s in one of these beautiful little bites. Please remember, this is a general estimate based on the ingredients I used here, especially since the exact sugar content of your crushed peppermint candies can vary. Don’t treat this like a strict doctor’s analysis; just a handy guide for your holiday planning!

Here’s the approximate breakdown when these easy peppermint cookies are divided into 24 servings:

• Serving Size: 1 cookie
• Calories: 150
• Sugar: 15g (Yes, it’s a holiday cookie, folks!)
• Fat: 8g (Mostly from that essential butter!)
• Saturated Fat: 5g
• Sodium: 50mg
• Carbohydrates: 19g
• Protein: 2g
• Cholesterol: 25mg

See? Not bad at all for a homemade, festive treat! If you’re watching your sugar intake, remember that using a slightly higher-quality peppermint candy can sometimes cut down on unnecessary fillers. Enjoying these in moderation is the key to a happy holiday season, so go ahead and have two!

Share Your Holiday Baking Success

Now that you’ve made a batch (or three!) of these glorious Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays, I seriously can’t wait to see what you came up with! Did they spread perfectly? Did the kids help smash the candies? Hearing about your baking moments is truly my favorite part of sharing recipes.

If you loved how simple and festive these were, please do me a huge favor and come back here to leave a star rating! Stars help other busy bakers find this foolproof recipe when they’re stressing out over their holiday schedules, and that’s the whole goal, right? Five stars if they made your house smell amazing!

Show Me Your Festive Creations!

Snap a picture of your finished cookies! I love seeing them lined up on cooling racks or piled high on holiday platters. Tag me on social media when you share your gorgeous photos of your easy peppermint cookies. Seriously, seeing all that red and white crunch brings me so much joy.

If you’re a social media person, use the hashtag #FreddyBakesMints or something similar, and I promise I’ll be cheering you on from my kitchen. It’s so much fun to see this recipe travel from my oven to yours!

Tell Me Your Holiday Cookie Tradition

While you’re here, I’d also love for you to drop a comment down below. We all have that one cookie that defines our holidays, right? Maybe it’s a gingerbread house that takes three days, or maybe it’s a simple spiced shortbread. I’m always looking to add new traditions to my list!

What is your absolute, number-one, must-have holiday cookie that you pull out every single year? Let me know! I’m building my list for next year, and I’d be thrilled if these Delightful Easy Peppermint Cookies For The Holidays became your new essential go-to!

Print